The Macallan 18 Double Cask vs. Sherry Oak Cask

When it comes to single malt Scotch whisky, few names command as much respect and reverence as The Macallan. Known for its dedication to quality, cask curation, and rich heritage, The Macallan has built a legacy of excellence. Among its highly coveted expressions, the 18 Year Old releases stand out as premium offerings that bridge the gap between accessible luxury and collector-grade whisky. But even within the 18-year range, enthusiasts are presented with a choice: the Double Cask or the Sherry Oak Cask?

So how do these two expressions differ? Let’s break down their flavour profiles, production methods, price points, and even where in the world they are most enjoyed.

The Basics: What Are They?

The Macallan 18 Double Cask and The Macallan 18 Sherry Oak Cask are both 18-year-old single malts, aged exclusively in oak casks seasoned with sherry. However, they differ in the type of oak used.

• The Macallan Double Cask 18: Aged in a combination of American oak and European oak sherry-seasoned casks.
• The Macallan Sherry Oak 18: Aged exclusively in European oak casks seasoned with Oloroso sherry from Jerez, Spain.

This difference in wood type and origin has a profound impact on the whisky’s flavour profile and overall character.

How They’re Made: Cask Influence is Key

Both whiskies start with the same base: The Macallan’s new make spirit, distilled in their iconic small stills for richness and complexity.

The major difference lies in the cask program:

• Sherry Oak Cask 18 uses 100% European oak casks, which tend to be denser and more tannic. These casks are crafted from oak grown in Spain and seasoned with Oloroso sherry for up to two years before being filled with whisky. The result is a more intense, spice-forward dram.
• Double Cask 18, on the other hand, combines European oak with American oak sherry-seasoned casks. American oak imparts creamier, sweeter notes—think vanilla and caramel—while still retaining that sherried richness from the seasoning process.

The blending of these casks is a balancing act, and The Macallan’s whisky makers carefully select and marry the casks to create a smooth yet complex whisky.

Flavour Profiles: What to Expect in the Glass

The Macallan 18 Sherry Oak Cask

• Nose: Dried fruits, ginger, clove, orange zest, and oak spice.
• Palate: Rich and full-bodied. Notes of sherry-soaked raisins, dark chocolate, wood smoke, and spice.
• Finish: Long, warming, and dry with lingering oak and fruitcake-like sweetness.

This one’s for the traditionalist—the whisky lover who enjoys depth, spice, and a more classic sherry-matured profile.

The Macallan 18 Double Cask

• Nose: Toffee, vanilla, warm spices, and a subtle citrus note.
• Palate: Balanced and creamy. Think fudge, honey, baked apple, and hints of dried fruit with gentle oak.
• Finish: Smooth, sweet, and slightly spiced. Softer than the Sherry Oak with less tannic dryness.

The Double Cask is ideal for those who want a more rounded and slightly sweeter experience without losing the hallmark Macallan richness.

Price Points: What’s the Cost of Luxury?

The Macallan 18 expressions are premium whiskies, and their prices reflect that.

• Sherry Oak 18 typically retails for €350–€450, depending on the market and availability. It’s often more expensive due to the higher cost of European oak and longer demand.
• Double Cask 18 usually lands slightly lower, in the €300–€400 range. It is still a luxury product but slightly more accessible.

Collectors and investors often favour the Sherry Oak version due to its consistency and long-standing reputation. However, both whiskies are considered good candidates for collecting and gifting

Global Demand: Who’s Buying?

The Macallan enjoys worldwide popularity, but a few markets stand out when it comes to their 18-year-old expressions:

1. United States

The U.S. is one of The Macallan’s largest markets, and the Double Cask expression is especially popular due to its sweeter, more approachable profile. American collectors and investors are also active in snapping up both 18-year-old editions.

2. China and Hong Kong

Luxury whisky is a status symbol in many Asian markets, and The Macallan is often viewed as the pinnacle of Scotch whisky. The Sherry Oak 18 is particularly revered here, both as a premium drink and an investment piece.

3. United Kingdom and Europe

The UK and Europe have long histories with single malt Scotch. While both expressions are available, the Sherry Oak tends to be the more sought-after due to its traditional profile and limited availability.

4. Travel Retail (Duty-Free)

Airport duty-free shops in major international hubs see brisk sales of both 18-year-old versions, especially around the holidays or festive seasons.

Final Verdict: Which One Should You Choose?

It ultimately comes down to preference:

• Choose Sherry Oak 18 if you want a bold, spicy, and classic Macallan with deep sherry richness and structure.
• Opt for Double Cask 18 if you prefer a smoother, sweeter, and more balanced whisky that still carries the signature Macallan DNA.
• Both are exceptional, both are collectable, and both represent the craftsmanship and care that The Macallan is famous for.

So whether you’re buying to savour, to gift, or to invest, you can’t go wrong—just know what experience you’re after.

Have you tried either (or both) of these Macallan 18 expressions? Let us know your thoughts and favourites in the comments or on social media. Slàinte!

Would you like this adapted for a whisky newsletter or paired with image recommendations?