Picking a calorie tracker isn’t just a lifestyle choice — it’s a decision that directly affects how accurate your data is, how long you stick with the habit, and whether the app grows with your health goals. The lose it vs mynetdiary debate comes up constantly, and for good reason: both apps are well-established, widely used, and genuinely capable. But when you look at the numbers side by side, the differences are significant.
Database Size vs. Database Quality
Lose It! claims over 60 million food items, the largest database in the category. That sounds impressive until you understand how it was built: almost entirely through crowdsourcing. Users submit entries that go live with minimal professional review. The result is duplicate records, conflicting calorie counts, and outdated data for reformulated products.
MyNetDiary takes the opposite approach. Its 2M+ database is built on USDA and NCC research-grade sources, staff-verified daily, with 2,500–3,500 new food submissions reviewed by trained nutrition staff before going live. Smaller, but meaningfully more reliable when accuracy matters.
Nutrient Depth: Not Even Close
This is where the gap becomes hard to ignore. MyNetDiary tracks 108 nutrients per food entry — including amino acids and omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acid subtypes- across every tier, including the free version. Lose It! tracks just 4 nutrients on the free tier (basic food label values) and 27 on its paid Premium plan.
For anyone managing a health condition, working with a dietitian, or simply wanting a complete picture of their nutrition, that difference is substantial.
Free Tier: What You Actually Get Without Paying
MyNetDiary’s free tier includes barcode scanning, voice logging, full 108-nutrient tracking, custom macro targets, a shopping list, and zero ads, with no account or email address required. Lose It! places barcode scanning, voice logging, and custom macro targets behind its $79.99/year Premium paywall, and its free tier shows ads. Some Premium subscribers have also reported seeing intrusive ads despite paying.
Logging Speed Matters More Than You Think
In a January 2026 iOS test covering 127 food entries across a full week, MyNetDiary required 711 actions to complete the log. Lose It! required 872 — 23% more effort for identical results. Over months of daily use, that friction quietly kills consistency.
User Ratings Tell the Story
In an April 2026 analysis of 2,995 App Store reviews, MyNetDiary averaged 4.54 out of 5. Lose It! averaged 3.46. Recent reviewers of Lose It! frequently cited UI changes that added extra logging steps and the shift of the barcode scanner behind the paywall.
Platforms like https://www.mynetdiary.com/ earn high satisfaction scores by solving the same problems that frustrate users on competing apps: slow logging, paywalled basics, and unreliable food data.
The Verdict
Choose Lose It! if social challenges, group competitions, and a multilingual interface are your priorities. Choose MyNetDiary if you want verified data, deeper nutrition insights, faster logging, and a genuinely useful free experience, without compromising on accuracy.
- About the Author
- Latest Posts
Our Editorial Team are writers and experts in their field. Their views and opinions may not always be the views of Wellbeing Magazine. If you are under the direction of medical supervision please speak to your doctor or therapist before following the advice and recommendations in these articles.
